View Mobile Site

Ask the Expert

Signal Photos


For whom the lane tolls

Posted: April 28, 2014 2:00 a.m.
Updated: April 28, 2014 2:00 a.m.

I just got back from a series of business trips in the east. I was able to visit the garden spots of Pittsburgh, Topeka, Kansas City, and Philadelphia. I was never so glad to get back home.

Not that those places are bad. I really liked getting snow in Pittsburgh. In April.

Having that cold wind cut through me like a hot knife through butter. Not seeing the sun. Not getting any decent Mexican food.

And I just love paying tolls on roads and interstate highways. Back east, one comes to expect seeing the toll booth rising up on the road ahead and dropping in a couple of quarters. It’s now part of the landscape.

In Chicago, they built most of the freeways out of the city by charging tolls to the users. They told the citizens that the tolls would end when the highways were paid for.

Odd, but this bill never seems to get paid.

Twenty to 30 years later, Chicagoans are still throwing their change in the basket to support what is nowa massive bureaucracy that has nothing to do with the original construction of the road.

However, we do not expect to see massive toll road systems here. Until now.

The San Gabriel Valley Tribune reported last Wednesday that the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transit Authority is now making permanent a pay lane system on the 110 and 10 freeways.

You now have the option of paying between 25 cents and $1.40 per mile based on traffic congestion.

You go to Costco, buy a transponder that goes on your dashboard, place a deposit in your account, and they begin deducting each time you drive in the Express Lanes.

Of course, car pools are free. For now. You must have at least two people in your car on the 110 and three folks on the 10.

News flash: Metro board members are apoplectic with glee (or greed?). Board member John Fasna was quoted as saying, “Overall, (the program) is positive. It merits continuation.”

Yeah, Johnny. It has netted Metro $34 million in revenues over the first year trial period.

Something important is being missed here. Toll roads are typically implemented to build something and have the users pay for it.

For example, the 73 down in Orange County is a toll road built and financed by tolls. The Chicago freeways were built on the same model.

The 110 and 10 freeways were built with public funds. They are the property of the state of California and, by inference, the people of California.

The tolls being charged on these public roads are not being used to build or improve them. They are simply a new tax imposed by local agencies as a revenue device.

This is not acceptable. In effect, we are being charged a use tax to enjoy a piece of property that we have already paid for.

And don’t think you car-poolers are safe. Those diamond lanes were just a first step to prepare us for the eventual taxation of all users of our public highways. You will pay too. It’s just a matter of time.

What is truly ironic is that diamond lanes were sold to Californians as a way to be more green and ecologically friendly. Ride with a buddy and slow down global warming. We now see that this was never the intent.

True, arguments are being made that this initiative forces drivers to car pool and relieve pressure from our roads.

The problem is, we made a conscious decision years ago to build super-freeways as our principle mode of transportation.

Eastern cities such as Pittsburgh and Philadelphia have public transportation systems that allow people to avoid driving.

All last week, I rode Pittsburgh’s “T” system every day to work. In fact, it is completely free in the downtown area.
Los Angeles — and most of California, for that matter — have no comparable system.

Converting freeways (emphasis on “free”) to toll roads is simply wrong. It is not a matter of friendly ecology as much as a way for governmental agencies to create new revenue streams. It must stop.

Our local supervisor, Mike Antonovich, has reservations.

Please email or call his office and tell him that the misappropriation of our traffic system by greedy politicians does not serve the public interest.

I think I’ll go back to Topeka.

Steve Lunetta is a resident of Santa Clarita and is going to start charging Metro for not using its toll lanes. That will fix ‘em. He can be reached at


ricketzz: Posted: April 28, 2014 6:13 a.m.

Freeways are wrong, period. Autos are obsolete and wasteful. The postwar era of sprawl is over. Once we get the carbon tax in place you will beg for trains.

17trillion: Posted: April 28, 2014 8:16 a.m.

Your cave is calling you ricketzz.

tech: Posted: April 28, 2014 9:20 a.m.

Ricketzz thinks Metro is just playing at parasitic behavior. He wants bloated bureaucracies to tax ALL activity.

Think the cost of basics has gone up at Costco, for example? A carbon tax will increase costs to be born by the consumer in every link of the supply chain for every product and service. In advanced economies, it's the equivalent of taxing respiration.

Monies raised will be promised for public good and subsequently redirected per Mr. Lunetta's example.

Open your eyes and perceive reality.

CastaicClay: Posted: April 28, 2014 12:08 p.m.

When construction began on the carpool and truck lanes between Lyons and the 14 there was no mention of toll lanes.
The toll lane was proposed from Lyons to Castaic. Did something change?

Lotus8: Posted: April 28, 2014 2:42 p.m.

Keep overwhelmingly voting for one party (Democrats) and watch the nonsense only get worse over time. Single party rule with no fear of being unseated is what leads to massive corruption. I don't care if everyone was voting Republican in this state, the same concept would hold true. This is why we also need to quit voting for political families who get worse with each iteration (Bush, Clinton, Kennedy, etc.). Davis, Arnold and Brown are three clowns who have each been disasters in the governor's mansion.

But when the average American can barely balance their own checkbook, how can you expect them to understand how the educated bureaucrats are robbing them blind through complex schemes?

We can all whine on this site about toll lanes, but the government beast in LA County will just continue on defiantly and screw us all over. The governor will still ram his train down our throats. Why? Because the public keeps supporting them regardless.

Allan_Cameron: Posted: May 21, 2014 7:45 p.m.

It is fascinating to read the history of rapid, public transportation in Southern California.

Prior to 1954, there was a fabulous system here known as "the big red car".

It was an all electric light rail system that had about 750 miles of installed service lines. Our present freeway system has just over 500 miles.

The lines went from downtown LA to Reseda, Downtown LA to Venice, Downtown LA to Long Beach, and many more sensible, prescient service areas.

These is a photo on the internet of the center of what is now the Hollywood
Freeway, taken in the 40's. It shows, located in what is now the center freeway median, two rail lines.

One electric train car is headed on one track to downtown. Another car is headed in the opposite direction to the San Fernando Valley.

We do not have that system now, because of a three way, criminal conspiracy among Standard Oil of California, Firestone Tire, and General Motors. These three entities were investigated, charged, tried and convicted.

They confessed to their crimes based upon a stated desire to sell more gasoline, tires, buses and cars.

The company executives were fined only a small token. Nome were sent to prison.

As a result of this historic crime, Southern California will never have a decent public transportation alternative to what we have now, which is personal, rapid, point to point, on demand transportation. (cars).

Making movement more expensive and difficult is inhumane and foolish. The solution is fairly straight forward. First are the simple, inexpensive solutions we experienced during the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics. Despite the traffic increases from 6 million visitors, we had traffic flowing freely at all times of the day.

Secondly, we need electric cars, charged with decentralized solar and wind energy. The big, central electric systems are obsolete and too expensive.

Mr. Lunetta, who usually writes fiction, makes excellent points here about social justice, freedom, and fairness.

There is a lot we can do here in Santa Clarita regarding this challenge. Perhaps someone will take up this issue, and do something.

You need to be a registered user to post a comment. Please click here to register.

The Signal encourages readers to interact with one another, following the guidelines outlined in our Comment/Moderation Policy. Click here to read it.

To report offensive or inappropriate comments, e-mail The content posted from readers of does not necessarily represent the views of The Signal or Morris Multimedia. By submitting this form you agree to the terms and conditions listed above. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.


Powered By
Morris Technology
Please wait ...