View Mobile Site
 

Ask the Expert

Signal Photos

 

Guidelines and parameters for Signal Opinion columnists

Posted: January 5, 2010 4:02 p.m.
Updated: January 5, 2010 4:03 p.m.
 

Local columns must be emailed to letters@signalscv.com for consideration.

Political commentary is the backbone of The Signal's Opinion page. While syndicated columnists who address state, national or world issues are part of our mix, our focus as a community newspaper is on local columnists who address local issues, and we welcome your contributions.

To be considered for publication, all Opinion columnists must follow and comply with the guidelines and parameters below. Column submissions that fail to do so will not be published.

Columns should be no longer than 750 words in length.

Columns will be edited by Signal staff. If the editor determines significant changes must be made due to length or content, the column may be returned to you for further editing.

Columnists may suggest one or more headlines, but the published headline will be decided by Signal staff. Columnists do not have final say or any approval rights on edits. We regret that time does not allow a discussion between the columnist and Signal staff regarding edits prior to publication.

A column is essentially an essay. With that in mind, we offer the following column-writing "do's":

* Do have a clear point, and make it just one clear point. A practiced essayist may be able to imply the point of his/her essay, but we recommend a clear statement of the point - what essayists call a thesis statement.

We don't want readers scratching their heads at the end of the column and asking themselves, "Now, what was that all about?"

* Do have a clear goal, which is usually persuasion. Unless the goal is strictly informational, which political columns usually are not (Dan Walters of the Sacramento Bee being an occasional exception), your column should be aimed at persuading readers to agree with your point of view and/or to take action on your arguments.

The most effective way to persuade is by logical, reasoned argument. That's not to say emotion can't be part of an effective argument, but arguments should be grounded in a logical appeal. Each argument should be supported by specifics -- examples, analogies, anecdotes.

Alternatively, the column may recount one long story/anecdote that illustrates your point, but it should be specific and well told.

* Do have an awareness of audience. Our audience is, of course, The Signal's readers. It's not just the City Council or a water board or town council. It's much broader than that. Address the public.

* Do seek fresh, thoughtful topics. Trust your personal impressions/feelings, but analyze them for logic. Being a local paper, we of course value columns that deal with local issues. But if we've already published 16 columns on the hospital expansion, for example, we would appreciate it if you sought topics elsewhere -- unless, of course, you have a spanking-new perspective that nobody else has mentioned.

* Back up your claims. Attribute your information. It will add credibility to your point of view. "A recent poll said that..." is not enough. Cite the poll, study or whatever, who or what entity released it, and when. Provide a Web address if possible. Columns with unattributed information will be returned for revision.

We cannot emphasize strongly enough the following: Plagiarism of any kind will not be tolerated.

Put simply, plagiarism is the theft of intellectual property. It is stealing other people's ideas -- not just their words, but their thoughts -- and passing those off as one's own.

Avoiding plagiarism can be as simple as noting: "An essay by so-and-so says this ..." - reminding the reader of the attribution frequently and quoting the author when appropriate.

Also, we offer some column-writing "don'ts":

* Don't write lengthy introductions. We're happy you visited Luxembourg, but there's a reason that "How I spent my summer vacation" is a cliché for clichés.

* Don't crusade. A columnist with only one cause is boring. It's unlikely a Signal columnist will, through his or her writing, succeed at halting all illegal immigration or leading a coup at City Hall. Give it a rest and write about something different. Remember the editor's job is, among other things, to provide a variety of reading options for our audience.

* No shameless plugs. You're attempting to sell your point of view, not a product or service.

* Don't engage in mudslinging and shrill accusations. That's counterproductive. True, public figures such as City Council members are virtually impervious to libel. But if your goal is persuasion, are you going to win hearts by calling the opposition the slime of the earth? No. Name-calling does not constitute an argument; all it does is drive away everyone who doesn't already agree with you. A reasoned argument will be much more effective.

Thank you for your interest in contributing to The Signal's Opinion page. We look forward to helping you share your voice with the community.

Comments

Commenting not available.
Commenting is not available.

 
 

Powered By
Morris Technology
Please wait ...